AINA Mission Execution Board
A VDS-first control surface for executing the full personalization engine mission.
The mission runs on /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room on the VDS, not Ali's Mac. Freshly rerun bounded Hugging Face downloads now flow through processed Economic Index/GDPval maps, legacy Economic Index wage/employment/task signals, an O*NET 30.3 public-source snapshot, cached-only BLS OEWS wage/employment fact import guard, an HF runtime map receipt, source-authority beta-wedge audit, beta admission policy, source-backed workflow packets, workflow-level AI affordance contracts, CurriculumInputPacket, typed readiness snapshots, deterministic planner v1, function-archetype fallback matrix, GDPval sandbox scenarios, sandbox payload contract, hardened local API contract fixture, dispatchable local API runtime, packet quality gate, deterministic evaluator fixture, learner event replay, deterministic feedback loop with evaluator-state matrix proof, local telemetry contract, review dashboard, static local learner wrapper, beta learner shell, content coverage gate, authored lesson-depth gate, rubric-depth gate, deployment-readiness gate, GDPval hold-closeout gate, GDPval calibration-packet gate, GDPval calibration-decision gate, GDPval replacement-closeout gate, GDPval replacement-reviewer-payload gate, GDPval replacement-domain-review gate, GDPval replacement-practice gate, GDPval replacement-replay-bridge gate, GDPval replacement-approved-intake gate, GDPval replacement-candidate-pack gate, GDPval replacement-candidate-review gate, GDPval replacement-candidate-practice gate, production-deployment-approval gate, and VDS runtime runbook. The simplified replacement rubric now passes local internal synthetic practice through the deterministic evaluator and can be translated into a five-case synthetic replay/feedback-preview matrix without writing canonical learner history; the approved-intake gate inventories the existing reviewer/domain-approved HF-backed chain while creating 0 new approvals; the candidate-pack gate selects five additional HF-backed review-only replacement candidates with 0 approvals or unlocks; the candidate-review gate advanced two only toward local practice and kept three held for revision; the candidate-practice gate proves those two pass deterministic local practice, replay/feedback preview, and intake inventory while preserving the three holds and creating 0 intake/runtime/external/production unlocks; the next lane is closing or safely rewriting the three held candidates with fresh reviewer/domain evidence.
Current Execution State
| Item | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Execution host | VDS confirmed | hostname returned vmi3344880; current path is /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room. |
| Active goal | Reset to mission execution | Goal created for all milestones M0-M7 and slices 1-24. |
| Branch | In progress | ali/personalization-engine-mission-2026-06-09. |
| Remote | Missing by design | No configured remote in this checkout; Ali asked for VDS-local git without push or merge ceremony. |
| Latest implementation checkpoint | Current slice | gdpval-replacement-candidate-practice scales only the two candidate-review approvals into local practice/replay/intake inventory. Current receipt: candidate_practice_replay_intake_ready_local_only, 2 approved candidates practiced, 2 deterministic evaluator passes, 10 replay/feedback previews, 16 synthetic events in a separate event log, 2 approved-intake inventory items, 3 revision-requested candidates held, 6 required edits preserved, 220 processed GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, 0 approved-intake runtime unlocks, 0 canonical learner-history writes, 0 progression unlocks, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks. |
| Slice 1 | Implemented | Source truth ledger and HF revision locks are required by validation. |
| Slice 2 | Implemented with expanded receipt | hf-ingest downloads and processes bounded real Hugging Face files, including legacy Economic Index wage/employment/task signals; hf-map-report proves the maps land on packets, workflows, curriculum/API, sandbox, beta shell, and review dashboard; validate now requires that receipt and fails stale HF counts. |
| Slices 3 and 4 | Implemented v1 with BLS fact cache gap | source-snapshots downloads/caches official O*NET 30.3 files, writes O*NET occupation/task parquet plus canonical_occupation_snapshot.parquet, and ingest now builds the warehouse from onet_30.3_snapshot. BLS OEWS metadata access is attempted and recorded; wage/employment facts are cached-only from official oe.data.0.Current, with the live VDS currently recording 0 fact rows. |
| Slice 6 | Implemented v0 | Workflows are derived from HF Economic Index/O*NET top tasks or market-source title evidence and carry workflow_source metadata plus source refs. |
| Slice 7 | Implemented v1 | AIAffordancePack carries one workflow-level contract per top workflow, with grants, blocks, HITL checkpoints, tools, risk, failure modes, and source refs. |
| Slice 8 | Implemented v1 | source-authority audits 11 representative beta families, and beta-admission converts that audit into explicit internal beta scope: 5 approved, 6 human-review-required, 0 blocked in the current receipt, with public release, external writes, and real-user data blocked. |
| Slices 5, 9, 12 | Implemented v1 | Role contract, CurriculumInputPacket, and evidence-aware deterministic planner v1 are in runtime validation. |
| Slice 10 | Implemented v1 | Direct aliases such as Founder/CEO are auditable alias matches; ambiguous domain titles can land on deterministic function archetypes; generic unknown fallback remains low-confidence; excluded software/engineering titles remain lookup-only and restricted. |
| Slice 11 | Implemented v1 | ReadinessSnapshot is now a typed contract on learner profiles, curriculum packets, learning paths, API fixtures, and eval fixtures. |
| Slice 13 | Implemented v19 | Curriculum exercise/rubric links attach to GDPval scenarios where available, fallback rubrics stay source-ref backed, all 48 representative modules resolve role/level-aware source-foundation content-node IDs plus exercise and rubric links, authored-lesson-depth proves 48/48 modules are role-fit, level-fit, signal-dense, pedagogy-backed, workflow/AI-affordance grounded, and free of generated source-path pollution, rubric-depth validation proves actionable source-resolved HF-context rubrics, GDPval hold closeout proves selected runtime GDPval tasks have reference/deliverable evidence before beta practice, GDPval calibration packet proves the remaining large rubric is reviewer-ready, GDPval calibration decision records that the original GDPval task stays held with replacement required, GDPval replacement closeout records the local-only simplified replacement path traced to processed HF data, the reviewer-banned-term gate proves 0 stale terms, reviewer payload records an approve_internal decision with 0 required edits, GDPval replacement domain review applies that payload for local internal synthetic practice, gdpval-replacement-practice proves the approved substitute passes deterministic practice, gdpval-replacement-replay-bridge proves that practice can be replay-shaped only in a separate synthetic review lane, gdpval-replacement-approved-intake proves the approved chain can be inventoried without creating fake approvals or unlocking external/public/unattended/production use, gdpval-replacement-candidate-pack selects five additional HF-backed candidate tasks, gdpval-replacement-candidate-review records 2 local-only candidate approvals plus 3 revision holds, and gdpval-replacement-candidate-practice proves those 2 approvals pass deterministic local practice/replay/intake inventory while preserving the 3 holds. |
| Slice 14 | Implemented v4 | replay-events dedupes append-only runtime/evaluator events into deterministic decision timelines and recommendation states; gdpval-replacement-replay-bridge and gdpval-replacement-candidate-practice now prove synthetic replacement-practice events can cover pass, revision, review-hold, pending-evaluation, and decision-generated states from separate logs without appending to canonical learner history, while approved intake keeps those bridge receipts in inventory-only scope with 0 canonical learner-history writes. |
| Slice 15 | Implemented v7 | Deterministic fixture scoring, PracticeSubmission, EvaluationResult, CLI command, tests, and validation checks are in place; gdpval-replacement-practice builds a synthetic curriculum/submission for the approved replacement and proves it passes the deterministic evaluator, gdpval-replacement-replay-bridge converts that approved item into a five-case review-only synthetic replay/feedback matrix without progression unlocks, approved intake validates that future scale must arrive through explicit reviewer/domain approval evidence, and gdpval-replacement-candidate-practice proves the two reviewed HF-backed approvals pass evaluator coverage while three revision candidates stay out of practice/replay/intake/runtime. |
| Slice 16 | Implemented v1 | GDPval train parquet is processed into 220 tasks; all 220 rubric-backed tasks now become sandbox scenarios across 44 SOC groups through a curated GDPval occupation-to-SOC crosswalk, with 10 no-match rationales for unsupported target roles and flags for missing attachments or penalty-style rubrics. |
| Slice 17 | Implemented v0 | sandbox-payload emits a valid GDPval-backed local payload fixture with prompt, tools, HITL, failure modes, rubric, source refs, and HF file refs. |
| Slice 18 | Implemented v2 | api-contract defines the hardened boundary, and api-runtime dispatches assess, curriculum, sandbox, and submit through the same handlers with safe 401 auth-block proof, HF-backed curriculum refs, GDPval sandbox file refs, and no external writes. |
| Slice 19 | Implemented and expanded | packet-quality-gate, content-coverage, authored-lesson-depth, rubric-depth-gate, deployment-readiness, gdpval-hold-closeout, gdpval-calibration-packet, gdpval-calibration-decision, gdpval-replacement-closeout, gdpval-replacement-reviewer-payload, gdpval-replacement-domain-review, gdpval-replacement-practice, gdpval-replacement-replay-bridge, gdpval-replacement-approved-intake, gdpval-replacement-candidate-pack, gdpval-replacement-candidate-review, gdpval-replacement-candidate-practice, and production-deployment-approval CLIs, JSON/JSONL/Markdown/HTML artifacts, tests, lint, and full validation pass; authored content coverage proves 48/48 representative modules with content/exercises/rubrics, authored lesson depth proves 48/48 depth-ready modules with 0 gaps, GDPval closeout proves 0 file-availability blockers, calibration packet proves 1 remaining review packet with 0 auto-approval, calibration decision records 1 keep-held outcome with replacement required, replacement closeout records 1 HF-traced simplified local substitute with 8 rewritten criteria and 0 reviewer-banned terms, reviewer payload records approve_internal with 0 required edits, domain review applies that payload for local internal synthetic practice, replacement practice proves 1/1 deterministic evaluator pass, replacement replay bridge proves 5 replay/feedback cases with 0 canonical event-log writes, approved intake records 1 approved item with 0 new approvals created, candidate pack records 5 additional review-only candidates from 69 eligible HF-backed tasks with 0 approvals or unlocks, candidate review records 5/5 candidate evidence receipts with 2 local-only approvals, 3 revision requests, 6 required edits, candidate practice records 2/2 deterministic evaluator passes, 10 replay/feedback previews, 2 approved-intake inventory items, 3 revision holds preserved, and 0 canonical/external/production unlocks, and production approval records 5 blocked deployment domains with 0 approved unlocks. |
| Slice 20 | Implemented v0 | telemetry-contract emits PostHog/Sentry-ready local envelope shapes, uses a VDS-local HMAC learner pseudonym, drops raw fields, rejects conversion errors, and keeps external writes disabled. |
| Slice 21 | Implemented v1 | beta-ui-shell writes the local beta learner loop plus local_learner_wrapper_v0.html, a static reviewable learner surface over the same in-process runtime, without starting a public server. |
| Slice 22 | Implemented v2 | feedback-loop and feedback-state-matrix convert replay/evaluator evidence into deterministic advance, revise, manual-review, evaluate, or wait recommendations and emit a re-ranked recommendation contract without mutating the stored planner output. |
| Slice 23 | Implemented v2 | review-queue converts packet quality gaps into stable local review items, and review-dashboard groups them into operator lanes with source refs, content coverage, GDPval linkage, beta-shell readiness, regenerated action states, closeout checks, Markdown/HTML companions, and validation checks. |
| Slice 24 | Implemented v1 | docs/runbooks/vds-hf-runtime-split-2026-06-09.md and HTML companion document the VDS/HF/cache/runtime split, deployment-readiness command, artifact map, and exact cold-start path. |
| Next lane | Local practice/replay scaling for reviewed candidates | The HF/runtime/content/review/source-authority/beta-admission/deployment-readiness/GDPval-closeout/calibration-decision/replacement-closeout/reviewer-payload/domain-review/practice/replay-bridge/approved-intake/candidate-pack/candidate-review/production-approval/authored-lesson-depth bridge exists, O*NET 30.3 backs the canonical occupation snapshot, BLS OEWS fact import is cached-only with a recorded live VDS gap, and candidate review has split the five selected HF-backed GDPval replacement candidates into 2 local-only practice-ready candidates and 3 revision-required holds. Next work should build deterministic practice/replay/intake coverage only for those 2 approved candidates, keep the 3 revision candidates held until their required edits close, and preserve the rule that synthetic receipts stay out of canonical learner history until explicit human approval exists. |
Subagent Findings
Mission backlog mapper
The backlog scout found that M0 is mostly represented, M7 is partially represented by the packet quality gate, and the remaining mission should run through the M1-M3 spine before API/UI work.
Source/HF lane scout
The source scout found that Hugging Face dependencies and source registry entries existed, but the registry did not yet download or join datasets. That gap is now closed for the bounded production path: hf-smoke locks dataset metadata, hf-ingest downloads selected Economic Index, legacy Economic Index signal, and GDPval files under a byte cap, records SHA-256 hashes, applies the curated GDPval occupation-to-SOC crosswalk, and produces derived role-signal maps. hf-map-report now proves the selected HF maps are attached across packet, workflow, curriculum/API, sandbox, beta-shell, and review-dashboard layers, including 821 SOC entries with legacy wage/employment/task signals. validate refreshes missing or stale HF ingest artifacts and requires verified selected downloads, derived map row counts, runtime API HF workflow/file refs, and the runtime map receipt. The GDPval warning still matters: reference and deliverable folders remain intentionally excluded from bulk download.
Source authority and beta wedge scout
The source-authority lane now has durable receipts: source-authority writes source_authority_beta_wedge_audit_v1 JSON/Markdown/HTML artifacts, and beta-admission writes beta_admission_v1 JSON/JSONL/Markdown/HTML artifacts. The source-authority receipt classifies seven source layers, verifies 15 selected Hugging Face files, confirms 756 Economic Index SOC rows, 821 legacy Economic Index signal rows, 220 GDPval tasks, 907 mapped SOC entries, includes the O*NET 30.3 public-source snapshot metrics, carries explicit BLS occupation metadata and wage/employment fact row counts, and audits 11 beta families across the packet corpus. The admission receipt then approves only low-risk, source-backed families for internal synthetic beta, holds sensitive or weak-market families for human review, and keeps BLS wage/employment claims blocked until official fact rows are cached or imported.
Runtime/contracts lane scout
The runtime scout originally called out missing packet/runtime contracts. Since then, CurriculumInputPacket, source-backed workflows, workflow-level affordance contracts, evaluator/replay/feedback fixtures, hardened API boundaries, local API runtime dispatch, full GDPval train-task scenario generation, safe runtime GDPval scenario ranking, no-match rationale credit in the quality gate, source-foundation content-node mapping, all-module exercise/rubric breadth checks, authored lesson-depth validation, rubric-depth validation, deployment-readiness hold routing, GDPval hold closeout, GDPval calibration decision, GDPval replacement closeout, GDPval replacement reviewer payload, GDPval replacement domain review, GDPval replacement practice, GDPval replacement replay bridge, GDPval approved intake, GDPval replacement candidate pack, production deployment approval, typed readiness snapshots, alias/function/generic fallback proof, evidence-aware planner factors, feedback-state re-ranking, stricter HF validation, O*NET 30.3 canonical snapshot loading, cached-only BLS OEWS fact import guard, telemetry contracts, beta learner shell proof, static local learner wrapper proof, review-dashboard action states, content coverage validation, source-authority beta-wedge review verdicts, and beta admission rules have landed; the remaining gap is attaching reviewer/domain evidence to the selected replacement-candidate IDs so the synthetic practice/replay matrix can scale without becoming fake learner history.
Milestone Execution Order
| Phase | Milestones | Why this order |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | M0 + M7 slice foundation | Mission plan and quality gate expose true gaps. |
| 2 | M1 source warehouse | Source truth must improve before workflow or GDPval claims become production-grade. |
| 3 | M2-M3 contract spine | Shared contracts are serial and central. |
| 4 | M4-M5 practice/evaluator/HF proof | Practice, evaluator, and GDPval depend on stable contracts. |
| 5 | M6-M7 API/UI/telemetry/scale | Product surfaces come after the core loop is evidence-backed. |
Slice Board
| Slice | Status | Owner mode | Next action |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Source truth ledger | Implemented | VDS local checkpoint | Keep adding source eligibility and license fields as new datasets enter. |
| 2 HF ingestion smoke | Implemented beyond smoke | VDS local checkpoint | Preserve capped ingest; validation now self-heals missing or stale HF ingest artifacts and requires verified selected downloads plus runtime HF refs. Do not bulk-download GDPval payload folders without an explicit future flag. |
| 3 O*NET/BLS canonical loader | Implemented v1 with BLS fact cache gap | VDS checkpoint | O*NET 30.3 selected text files are cached/downloaded, parsed to parquet, and used as onet_30.3_snapshot canonical occupation rows. BLS OEWS metadata access remains blocked from the VDS, and the official current data fact table is cached-only; validation records 0 BLS fact rows instead of inventing wage/employment values. |
| 4 Job/title intake guardrails | Guardrailed v1 | VDS checkpoint | source-authority fails if job/title market refs are polluted with HF refs or if HF replaces title-match authority, and full validation now distinguishes canonical O*NET rows from LinkedIn market-signal rows. |
| 5 Role normalization contract | Implemented v0 | Serial owner | Expand golden title fixtures and track weak or fuzzy matches. |
| 6 Workflow extraction contract | Implemented v0 | VDS checkpoint | Representative workflows carry HF/O*NET or market-source evidence refs, workflow_source metadata, and pass workflow-specificity gates. |
| 7 AIAffordancePack v1 | Implemented v1 | Serial owner | Keep the affordance_contract gate green as content and readiness coverage changes. |
| 8 Beta role wedge | Implemented v1 | VDS checkpoint | beta-admission converts 11 representative source-authority family audits into 5 internal-beta approvals, 6 human-review holds, blocked-status support, BLS gap disclosure, and hard no-public/no-external/no-real-user-data scope. |
| 9 CurriculumInputPacket | Implemented v0 | Serial owner | Add more planner evidence fields as scenario and evaluator data matures. |
| 10 Fallback resolver | Implemented v1 | Serial owner | Exact, alias, function-archetype, generic fallback, and excluded lookup-only cases are now tested and validated through fallback-matrix. |
| 11 Readiness assessment schema | Implemented v1 | Serial owner | Typed readiness snapshot covers AI usage, confidence, capacity, tools, evidence history, counts, start level, and quality flags. |
| 12 Planner scoring v1 | Implemented v1 | Serial owner | Planner now scores readiness fit, workflow value, and evidence fit; keep the feedback-state matrix green as authored content and real learner-event coverage expand. |
| 13 Lesson/exercise/rubric linker | Implemented v16 | VDS checkpoint | Scenario-backed links exist for GDPval-mapped SOCs; candidate modules now carry role/level-aware source-foundation content-node IDs; content coverage validates 48 modules with content, exercises, rubrics, and 62 unique content nodes; authored lesson depth validates 48/48 depth-ready modules with 0 gaps; rubric depth validates 48 actionable, source-resolved, HF-context module rubrics; GDPval hold closeout proves selected tasks have reference/deliverable evidence; GDPval reviewer payload now approves the simplified substitute for local internal synthetic practice only, domain review applies that payload, replacement practice proves the approved substitute passes the deterministic evaluator, replay bridge covers five synthetic states, and approved intake inventories the approved chain while creating 0 new approvals. |
| 14 Learner event ledger | Implemented v1 | VDS checkpoint | Event replay writes JSON/JSONL/Markdown/HTML artifacts, dedupes reruns, feeds validation, and the replacement replay/intake lane proves approved synthetic practice stays out of canonical learner history. |
| 15 Evaluator rubric engine | Implemented v2 | VDS checkpoint | Deterministic fixture scoring is wired into CLI, validation, rebuild, and tests; replacement practice now uses the same evaluator path for the approved HF-backed simplified rubric, and approved intake keeps future scale gated on reviewer/domain evidence. |
| 16 GDPval scenario linker | Implemented v1 | VDS worker | All 220 rubric-backed GDPval train tasks now become scenarios; unsupported target-role decisions have explicit no-match rationales that the quality gate now credits. |
| 17 Sandbox payload API | Implemented v0 | VDS checkpoint | Use the local payload fixture as the contract for future /workflow/{id}/sandbox; no public endpoint yet. |
| 18 Public API endpoints | Implemented v2 | VDS checkpoint | Local request/response contracts require auth context, route scopes, tenant scope, rate-limit policy, privacy-safe errors, no real-user data, and no external writes; api-runtime dispatches all four routes in-process and proves the safe denied-request path. No public server or deploy path yet. |
| 19 Packet/content/rubric quality audit | Implemented and expanded | Local/VDS serial | Keep packet quality, content coverage, authored-lesson-depth, rubric-depth, deployment-readiness, GDPval hold-closeout, GDPval calibration, GDPval replacement closeout, GDPval replacement reviewer payload, GDPval replacement domain-review, GDPval replacement practice, GDPval replacement replay bridge, GDPval approved intake, GDPval replacement candidate pack, and production-approval gates honest as scenario, human calibration, and evaluator coverage improve. |
| 20 Telemetry and observability | Implemented v0 | VDS checkpoint | Local PostHog/Sentry-ready envelope shapes exist with HMAC learner pseudonyms, raw-field drops, 15 validated events, 0 conversion errors, and external writes disabled. |
| 21 Beta UI path | Implemented v1 | VDS checkpoint | Local beta learner shell proves assessment, readiness, curriculum, preview lesson, sandbox prompt, submission result, and safety boundary using the local runtime; local_learner_wrapper_v0.html gives Ali a static reviewable learner surface without a public server. |
| 22 Feedback learning loop | Implemented v2 | VDS checkpoint | Feedback artifacts route replay states to advance/revise/manual-review/evaluate/wait actions, name the recommended module, and prove feedback_recommendation_v1 re-ranked module lists across five evaluator states. |
| 23 Review queue and dashboard | Implemented v2 | VDS checkpoint | Queue has stable gap items, and dashboard turns 12 review items into operator lanes with source evidence, content coverage, GDPval linkage, beta-shell readiness, regenerated action states, closeout checks, JSON/JSONL/Markdown/HTML artifacts, tests, and validation checks. |
| 24 Deployment runbook | Implemented v1 | VDS checkpoint | Runbook has exact cold-start commands, artifact map, HF boundaries, validation receipt, deployment-readiness proof, and HTML companion. |
Immediate Worker Queue
beta-admission converts review_ready_human_gate_required into approved, human-review-required, or blocked family scope. Current receipt: 5 approved for internal synthetic beta, 6 human-review-required, 0 blocked, with BLS gap disclosure and no public/external/real-user scope.source-snapshots now accepts cached official oe.data.0.Current, parses BLS series IDs for national cross-industry occupation wage/employment metrics, writes bls_oews_wage_employment_may_2025.parquet only when official rows pass schema/row checks, and keeps the live VDS valid with bls_wage_employment_rows=0 while public BLS access/cache is absent.rubric-depth-gate now validates 48/48 reviewed modules for actionable rubric criteria, source refs, locally resolved refs, HF context, and GDPval enrichment; it records 1 GDPval review hold for human follow-through without blocking the local production gate.deployment-readiness now consumes the HF/public-source/beta/API/UI/telemetry/review/rubric receipts and writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts. Current receipt: ready_with_review_holds, 15 selected HF files verified, 186,743,670 HF bytes processed, 1 GDPval held module routed to human calibration, 0 beta-practice file blockers, no public runtime, no external writes, no real-user data, external beta blocked, and public release blocked.gdpval-hold-closeout proves 9 selected GDPval tasks, 12 selected modules, 0 file-availability blockers, 1 remaining human-calibration hold, and local-only safety boundaries.gdpval-calibration-packet maps the remaining finance hold to the downloaded HF task row, source refs, 15 reference file URIs, 2 deliverable example URIs, 67 raw rubric items, 121 points, redacted sample criteria, reviewer actions, and blocked external/public/unattended boundaries with 0 auto-approvals.authored-lesson-depth writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts that validate 12 representative families and 48 modules for resolved authored lesson nodes, role fit, level fit, signal density, pedagogy signal, workflow/AI-affordance grounding, practice/rubric links, and source-path quality. The content selector now avoids generated prompt-packet/build output paths when authored source files are available. Current receipt: pass, 48/48 modules depth-ready, 0 gaps, GDPval calibration safely held, 0 auto-approvals, no public runtime, no external writes, and no real-user data.gdpval-calibration-decision records the final local evidence-bound decision for the remaining large finance GDPval rubric: keep held, replacement required, no approval, no auto-approval, no external beta, no public release, no unattended evaluation, no external writes, and no real-user data. The CLI has guardrails for future approval/replacement attempts.production-deployment-approval writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts that define approval evidence for any future public runtime, external writes, real-user data, production telemetry sinks, or deployment promotion. Current receipt: production_blocked_approval_required, 5 approval domains, 0 requested unlocks, 0 approved unlocks, 5 blocked domains, 1 open review hold, 1 GDPval keep-held decision, and no public/runtime/external/real-user/telemetry/deployment unlocks.gdpval-replacement-closeout writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts that record the local-only simplified authored replacement path for the remaining held finance GDPval rubric. Current receipt: replacement_path_recorded_review_required, 1 replacement item, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 1 processed HF task row resolved, 1 downloaded GDPval parquet source traced, max 67 raw rubric items reduced to 8 simplified criteria, original task still held, raw rubric and prompt not embedded, 0 external beta unblocks, 0 public release unblocks, 0 unattended-evaluation unblocks, no external writes, no real-user data, no production telemetry, and no deployment promotion.gdpval-replacement-domain-review writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts for the simplified replacement approval-evidence boundary. Current receipt: domain_review_approved_internal_only, 1 review item, reviewer payload 3b6a4073d9cfa3b9 applied, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 downloaded HF bytes, 1 processed HF task row resolved, 1 downloaded GDPval parquet source traced, 1 local internal synthetic-practice approval, original task still held, no external/public/unattended unlocks, no production telemetry, and no deployment promotion.gdpval-replacement-reviewer-payload writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts for the Claude subscription reviewer decision. Current receipt: reviewer_payload_recorded_approved_internal_only, payload 3b6a4073d9cfa3b9, 5 evidence refs, 0 required edits, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 downloaded HF bytes, 1 processed HF task row resolved, 1 downloaded GDPval parquet source traced, original task still held, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks.gdpval-replacement-practice writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts that exercise the approved simplified replacement through the deterministic evaluator. Current receipt: replacement_practice_passed_internal_only, 1 approved internal replacement, 1 practice item, 1/1 evaluator pass, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 downloaded HF bytes, 1 processed HF task row resolved, 1 downloaded GDPval parquet source traced, original task held, raw rubric and full prompt not embedded, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks.gdpval-replacement-replay-bridge writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, HTML, and separate synthetic event-log artifacts that translate the approved replacement-practice receipt into replay-shaped local review evidence without appending to the canonical learner event log. Current receipt: synthetic_replay_bridge_ready_review_only, 1 approved practice item bridged into 5 deterministic synthetic cases, 8 synthetic events, 5 synthetic replay records, all 5 replay states covered, all 5 feedback actions covered, 5 bridge holds for human review, 0 canonical event-log writes, no canonical learner-history writes, no progression unlocks, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks.gdpval-replacement-approved-intake writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts that inventory approved GDPval replacement items only after they are present in the HF-backed replacement closeout, reviewer payload, domain-review, practice, and replay-bridge receipts. Current receipt: approved_replacement_intake_ready_existing_only, 1 approved item inventoried, 0 optional candidate records supplied, 0 new approvals created, 1/1 approved items covered by deterministic practice, 1/1 approved items covered by replay bridge, 5 bridge cases covered, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, 0 canonical event-log writes, no canonical learner-history writes, no progression unlocks, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks.gdpval-replacement-candidate-pack writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, and HTML artifacts that select the next review-only GDPval replacement candidates from the processed HF task map without creating approvals. Current receipt: replacement_candidate_pack_ready_for_review, 5 candidate records selected, 69 eligible HF-backed tasks, 220 processed GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, 1 downloaded GDPval parquet source traced, 1 existing approved item excluded, 114 rows excluded for missing file evidence, 36 rows excluded for banned rubric terms, 0 new approvals, 0 practice-allowed candidates, no canonical learner-history writes, no progression unlocks, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks.gdpval-replacement-candidate-review attaches Claude CLI reviewer/domain evidence to every selected candidate ID from the HF-backed candidate pack. Current receipt: candidate_review_evidence_recorded_mixed, 5 candidates reviewed, 2 approved only for a local internal synthetic practice gate, 3 revision-requested candidates held, 6 required edits recorded, 20 per-item evidence refs, 220 processed GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, 0 approved-intake-ready candidates, 0 canonical learner-history writes, 0 progression unlocks, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks.gdpval-replacement-candidate-practice writes JSON, JSONL, Markdown, HTML, and separate synthetic event-log artifacts that scale only the two candidate-review approvals into local practice/replay/intake inventory. Current receipt: candidate_practice_replay_intake_ready_local_only, 2 approved candidates practiced, 2 deterministic evaluator passes, 10 replay/feedback previews, 16 synthetic events, 2 approved-intake inventory items, 3 revision-requested candidates held, 6 required edits preserved, 220 processed GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, 0 approved-intake runtime unlocks, 0 canonical learner-history writes, 0 progression unlocks, and 0 external/public/unattended/production unlocks.Validation Receipt So Far
uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room hf-ingest --max-bytes 500000000 uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room source-snapshots uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room build-foundations uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room ingest uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room build-packets uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room build-sandbox uv run pytest -q uv run ruff check . uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room packet-quality-gate uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room content-coverage uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room rubric-depth-gate --min-families 12 uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room authored-lesson-depth uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room review-queue uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room review-dashboard uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room hf-map-report uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room source-authority uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room beta-admission uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room eval uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room fallback-matrix uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room evaluate-fixture uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room sandbox-payload uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room api-contract uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room api-runtime uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room replay-events uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room feedback-loop uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room feedback-state-matrix uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room telemetry-contract uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room beta-ui-shell uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room deployment-readiness uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-hold-closeout uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-calibration-packet uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-calibration-decision uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room production-deployment-approval uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-closeout uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-reviewer-payload uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-domain-review uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-practice uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-replay-bridge uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-approved-intake uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-candidate-pack uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-candidate-review uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room gdpval-replacement-candidate-practice uv run aina-data-engine --root /srv/aina/aina-data-engine-room validate
Results: Public source snapshots are ready_with_bls_access_gap: O*NET 30.3 selected text files are cached/downloaded, 1,016 occupation rows, 18,796 task rows, 867 unique SOCs, canonical_occupation_snapshot.parquet is written, BLS OEWS May 2025 metadata was attempted and recorded as HTTP 403 from the VDS, cached-only oe.data.0.Current fact import is supported, and current live BLS wage/employment fact rows are recorded as 0. Hugging Face ingest verified 15 selected dataset files on disk; the ingest summary records 16 files including the local manifest, 186,743,670 bytes, 756 Economic Index SOC rows, 821 legacy wage/employment/task signal rows, 220 GDPval tasks, 907 mapped SOC entries, 821 SOC entries with legacy signals, and 44 SOC groups with GDPval links. HF runtime map receipt is ready: 15 selected files verified, 45,564 packets checked, 43,936 packets with HF refs, 7,906 packets with GDPval refs, 126,588 workflows with HF refs, 821 mapped SOCs with legacy signals, 4 curriculum modules, 4 exercise links, 4 rubric links, 17 curriculum HF refs, 11 curriculum GDPval refs, 220 sandbox scenarios, and 12 review-dashboard source-backed items. GDPval replacement practice is replacement_practice_passed_internal_only: 1 approved internal replacement, 1 practice item, 1/1 evaluator pass, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, original task held, raw rubric/full prompt not embedded, and no external/public/unattended/production unlocks. GDPval replacement replay bridge is synthetic_replay_bridge_ready_review_only: 1 approved practice item bridged, 5 deterministic synthetic cases, 8 synthetic events in a separate event log, 5 synthetic replay records, all five replay states and feedback actions covered, 5 human-review bridge holds, 0 canonical event-log writes, and no canonical learner-history/progression/external/public/unattended/production unlocks. GDPval replacement approved intake is approved_replacement_intake_ready_existing_only: 1 approved item inventoried, 0 candidates supplied, 0 new approvals created, 1/1 practice-covered approved item, 1/1 replay-bridge-covered approved item, 5 bridge cases, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, and no canonical/external/production unlocks. GDPval replacement candidate pack is replacement_candidate_pack_ready_for_review: 5 review-only candidates selected from 69 eligible HF-backed tasks, 1 existing approved item excluded, 114 rows excluded for missing file evidence, 36 rows excluded for banned rubric terms, 0 new approvals, 0 practice-allowed candidates, and no external/public/unattended/production unlocks. GDPval replacement candidate review is candidate_review_evidence_recorded_mixed: 5 selected candidate IDs reviewed, 2 approved only for local practice, 3 revision-requested candidates held, 6 required edits, 20 per-item evidence refs, 0 approved-intake-ready candidates, and no canonical/external/production unlocks. GDPval replacement candidate practice is candidate_practice_replay_intake_ready_local_only: 2 approved candidate-review items practiced, 2/2 deterministic evaluator passes, 10 replay/feedback previews, 16 synthetic events in a separate event log, 2 approved-intake inventory items, 3 revision-held candidates preserved, 6 required edits preserved, 220 processed HF GDPval task-map rows, 186,743,670 HF bytes, no canonical learner-history writes, no progression unlocks, no approved-intake runtime unlocks, and no external/public/unattended/production unlocks. Production deployment approval remains production_blocked_approval_required: 5 approval domains, 0 requested unlocks, 0 approved unlocks, and all public/runtime/external/real-user/telemetry/deployment unlocks blocked. Full validation is pass with replacement-practice, replay-bridge, approved-intake, candidate-pack, candidate-review, and candidate-practice artifacts now included alongside the public-source, HF, runtime, GDPval, review, feedback, telemetry, and packet-quality receipts. Full tests: 137 passed. Ruff: all checks passed.
Start by closing or safely rewriting the three revision-requested candidate IDs from
gdpval_replacement_candidate_review_v1, satisfying their six required edits, rerunning reviewer/domain evidence, and admitting only newly approved items into the same local-only candidate-practice/replay/intake inventory lane.