GDPval Candidate Batch Review
GDPval replacement candidate batch review records Claude CLI reviewer/domain evidence for the first backlog batch. It validates decisions but grants no practice, approved-intake, runtime, external, public, real-user-data, production telemetry, or deployment-promotion access.
The Single Idea
Claude reviewer decisions are recorded for the first backlog batch, but practice and runtime remain locked behind a later gate.
01
Snapshot
candidate_batch_review_evidence_recorded_mixedstatus
backlog_batch_001batch
10review items
3approved decisions
5revisions
2held
3future gate
0practice allowed
0unlocks
02
Checks
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| candidate_batch_review_input_exists | PASS |
| candidate_batch_review_input_schema_valid | PASS |
| claude_cli_source_recorded | PASS |
| reviewer_identity_present | PASS |
| reviewed_at_present | PASS |
| review_rationale_present | PASS |
| review_input_has_evidence_refs | PASS |
| candidate_review_batch_valid | PASS |
| candidate_review_batch_hf_evidence_ready | PASS |
| production_deployment_approval_valid | PASS |
| production_approval_keeps_all_domains_blocked | PASS |
| batch_reviews_cover_all_candidates | PASS |
| all_reviews_reference_known_candidates | PASS |
| all_reviews_match_candidate_task_ids | PASS |
| all_review_item_decisions_supported | PASS |
| mixed_review_outcomes_recorded | PASS |
| all_review_items_have_rationale | PASS |
| all_review_items_have_evidence_refs | PASS |
| all_review_items_match_source_refs | PASS |
| all_review_items_have_strengths_and_concerns | PASS |
| revision_and_hold_items_have_required_edits | PASS |
| approved_items_still_require_separate_practice_gate | PASS |
| all_reviews_resolve_processed_hf_rows | PASS |
| all_reviews_trace_downloaded_hf_files | PASS |
| all_reviews_have_reference_and_deliverable_files | PASS |
| all_reviews_have_simplified_criteria | PASS |
| raw_rubric_and_full_prompt_not_embedded | PASS |
| batch_review_creates_no_new_approvals | PASS |
| batch_review_not_practice_allowed | PASS |
| approved_intake_not_ready | PASS |
| no_canonical_learner_history_writes | PASS |
| no_progression_unlocks | PASS |
| no_external_or_production_unlocks | PASS |
03
Batch Review Items
| Batch Rank | Candidate | Occupation | Decision | Required Edits | Future Gate | Practice Allowed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | e866a3a1842ff61e | Project Management Specialists | approve_internal | 1 | True | False |
| 2 | 44dd0182f9d5964d | Project Management Specialists | request_revision | 3 | False | False |
| 3 | 5cc7d76f7a7977e3 | Administrative Services Managers | request_revision | 3 | False | False |
| 4 | c1228061bcc7d4bc | Order Clerks | approve_internal | 2 | True | False |
| 5 | 5f70bd36ac002709 | Shipping, Receiving, and Inventory Clerks | approve_internal | 1 | True | False |
| 6 | ae2558399be01682 | Customer Service Representatives | request_revision | 3 | False | False |
| 7 | 0ba3710aa05a043a | Recreation Workers | request_revision | 3 | False | False |
| 8 | b700d31ff15dbc4c | Recreation Workers | keep_held | 3 | False | False |
| 9 | c0e4be9d4e2c8f13 | Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Technical and Scientific Products | keep_held | 4 | False | False |
| 10 | 61d9a491f6708efa | Counter and Rental Clerks | request_revision | 4 | False | False |
Boundary
Reviewer approval is not practice admission; the next gate must handle confirmations, revision closeout, or keep-held redraft explicitly.
Reviewer approval is not practice admission; the next gate must handle confirmations, revision closeout, or keep-held redraft explicitly.